Even so, there have always been some who try to debunk Jesus. In
spite of his great moral teaching, his eye-witnessed healings, his impact on
history, and his affirmation by prophecy, they are convinced Jesus was the
greatest fraud of all time.
Hugh Schonfield, one such antagonist, wrote The Passover Plot in
1965, a travesty of half-truth and outright lies in which he tries to expose
Jesus as a false Messiah. He attempts to make the Lord into some sort of
trickster with bogus powers, allowing him to fake his person to the
unsophisticated, resulting in the New Testament. And according to
Schonfield the New Testament is all just a spurious fraud.
In The Passover Plot, this “conniver,” Jesus, set up all the ingredients
of his being recognized as Messiah in advance. He actually went out of
his way to get himself crucified by the Romans so he could be revived in
the “cool” of the Garden Tomb. By the way, according to Schonfield and
others, that “cool tomb” is apparently a detail of massive importance
missed by most historians. Somehow a cool tomb can even revive a man
after 40 lashes with his internals hanging out, with the accompanying loss
of most of his blood, and even after being declared dead by crucifixion!
But to even assert such a thing, Schonfield must have understood that
40 lashes with the Roman cat-o-nine tails was already considered an
execution. It would have opened his back to massive bleeding and
infection. And that, followed by hours on the cross, the shock, and even a
spear thrust into his side, (yielding blood and water separated, sure sign of
lung failure); convinces us that we know with certainty he died. In
actuality a cool tomb could do about as much to revive such a victim as
ice does for dead fish. Four professional crucifiers took him down and
declared his death, and no honest historian would be willing to joust with
such four experts. These men knew death. But even so, Jesus was revived
when he went into the tomb. Because, as Schonfield reveals, Jesus had
just swooned and the cool tomb revived him.
And when he woke up again, he was able to drag himself off to the
Apostles and convince them he was the expected Messiah, the very power
of God in heaven. And Josh likes to have fun with this scenario.
“After being whipped, crucified, and speared, Jesus just jumped up
from his shelf in the tomb. Still bound in the grave clothes, encased like a
mummy, and breathing through it all, he hobbled over to the door, pushed
a two-ton stone out of the way and tied up the guard outside with the linen
cloth.” Or something like that!
Well after all, it couldn’t have been too hard for him, having already
convinced these first century know nothings he could feed 5000 with a few
loaves and fishes, that he could walk on water, and still the storms! He
24